Utmost Spookiest Games: Fatal Frame

This game….. this game….


Fatal Frame may be the scariest game I’ve ever played. “Wretched” might be the best adjective to describe this game, as it oozes with an overpowering atmosphere of desolation, apprehension and dilapidation that is completely unique amongst the horror games I’ve played. Fatal Frame chronicles protagonist Miku Hinasaki’s terrifying investigation of the haunted Himuro mansion, a decrepit feudal Japanese castle that is the legacy of the depraved and extinct Himuro clan. In a classical horror fiction conceit, Himuro is in search of her brother who went missing during his own investigation of the sinister site. The main conceit of Fatal Frame (for which it is named) is the use of an antique camera, the Camera Obscura, to damage the malevolent ghostly denizens of the mansion by way of capturing the apparitions on film.


As I stated before, the most impressive aspect of Fatal Frame is the unrelenting atmosphere. Himuro mansion is in utter ruin but still intact enough to provide an ominous interior space that weighs on the player’s spirit. The mansion is musty, dark, and, as a result of its feudal origins, lacks windows in most of its rooms. These aspects create a feeling of unnerving isolation for which I know of no other comparison amongst the games I’ve played. The isolation is the key component in the tension that pervades the experience of this game. I’ve had some trouble getting through the game simply because I can only handle ~30-40 minute play sessions before the oppressiveness of it all just leaves me exhausted. I seem to remember this game releasing to rather tepid reception when it originally came out which leaves me utterly confused after playing through it now as it stands amongst the most horrifying games I’ve ever played.

Playing such an excellent example of a horror game makes me reflect on what actually makes for good horror in video games. I’ve always had a disagreement with a friend of mine over what actually makes a game scary. In his mind, he places a heavy emphasis on limited ammunition and encumbered combat. I, on the other hand, place focus on atmosphere and story. I think Resident Evil 4 is a good example that illustrates our differences. I find Resident Evil 4 to possibly be the scariest of the series. So many gruesomely dreadful locations and situations hang in my memory from that game, such as the initial assault at the village, the Regenerador lab, and the encounter with the Verdugo in the maintenance area. By contrast, my friend feels that Resident Evil 4 is the least scary of the series up to that point, as there is a relative abundance of ammo, healing items, and weapons which eliminates tension from combat. Personally, I don’t feel that such combat design really increases my dread in a game, perhaps because I’m always aware that I can just reload at the last save point if I die and therefore don’t perceive the same sense of danger.

This relates to Fatal Frame because, at least in my perspective, the game is least scary when you are actually under attack by a ghost. Combat with the ghosts is fairly simply. The ghosts float toward Miku, sometimes in unique patterns that the player has to adapt to, while the player tries to keep the camera focused on the ghost’s weak spot for as long as possible to build up the damage that will be inflicted when as shot is taken. If Miku is caught by a ghost, the entity just sort of shakes her for a little bit before it backs off. These experiences are not really all that frightening. The praise I give Fatal Frame is far more rooted in the dreadful atmosphere, aggressive suspense, the oppressive feeling of isolation, and the horrifying story that unfolds. Himuro Mansion is just a deeply discomforting place to walk around in, and the game keeps the player on their toes by sprinkling in some insanely creepy jump scares, cutscenes, and eery peripheral events.

In the end, I’ve been a little vague on specific examples of what makes this game work, but that is mainly because I want to avoid spoilers, as I feel this is a title any fan of horror games should seek out and play. It can currently be found in the PS2 classics selection for PS3 which is available via PSN, but physical copies can be found of the original PS2 and Xbox (the first Xbox 1) versions.

Posted on November 5, 2014, in Essays and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. Being a bit of a survival-horror fan back when this came out, I can remember scoffing at the ridiculous premise. Perfect example of why to never judge a book by its cover.

    Great post!


  2. I love this series. I’m in your friend’s camp of not seeing RE4 as scary, but Fatal Frame (or Project Zero as it’s called here in Europe) utterly terrified me. At least the third game did, I’ve only played through the beginning of the first. I’m baffled too by the mixed reception this series has, since Project Zero 3 is tied with Silent Hill 1 & 2 as the best horror game I’ve played. PZ3 filled me with utter dread in a way no other game has, plus the gameplay is extremely competent and well-done. To my mind, the mixed reception speaks volumes about the gaming media’s unjustified expectations for games – big budget, “mature” themed, heavily hyped… maybe the publishers just didn’t send any bribes to media outlets? Some combo of all above? I don’t know. Either way the net result is a sorely underrated, classic or near-classic series.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It’s good to hear positive things about the third game in the series! I haven’t played it yet, but most people only talk about the first and second one, so I wasn’t sure if the third one was good or not.

      Liked by 1 person

      • It is excellent, but when I started the first game I did wonder if the third game was something like a remake of the first. The opening location seems remarkably similar, if not the same, in terms of layout and stuff. Anyway according to Wikipedia they are different, so I’d trust that rather than my five minutes’ worth of impressions. I didn’t play more because I was Project Zero-ed out – the third game was so damn scary, I didn’t need a repeat!


  3. The Otaku Judge

    I agree that combat makes horror games less scary. Take the original Dead Space. It’s very creepy at first when you are walking through dimly lit corridors. The terror vanishes towards the end when it becomes more of a shooter were you are expected to blast multiple enemies at once.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: